|
Phony Degrees a Hot Net Scam
by Kendra Mayfield
Some college degrees aren't worth the parchment they're printed
on.
For a small fee an official Harrington University diploma
-- purportedly accepted anywhere in the world -- can be delivered
within 10 business days.
No coursework, grades, or academic experience required.
But Harrington University doesn't have a website, a campus,
or even accreditation.
"It's just between us how you got your diploma,"
said a representative from Harrington, a self-described diploma
mill that -- like other unaccredited schools -- uses Internet
and email marketing to lure prospective students.
Wired News contacted Harrington University through an anonymous
email ad. A representative who returned the call said that
for a "small fee" of $1,400 (and an additional $500
discount for signing up that day), applicants can obtain a
Bachelor's, Master's, or PhDs based on "life experience."
"You never have to complete courses because we give
credit for work and life experiences," the Harrington
registrar said.
With a custom-made PhD based on work experience, "You
can legally call yourself Doctor," the representative
said.
"The Internet has spawned a new generation of cyber-degree
mills," said Michael Lambert, executive director of the
Distance Education and Training Council.
"[Diploma mills] are growing, especially on the Internet,
at astonishing rates," agrees John Bear, founder of Degree.net.
Bear has witnessed the dark side of the distance-education
boom up close. A former consultant, informant, and expert
witness for the FBI's task force operation DipScam in the
1980s, he helped shut down a number of diploma mills over
a 12-year period.
Bear estimates that diploma mills rake in an average $200
million a year, with single schools earning between $10 and
$20 million annually.
And that number, he says, is conservative. He estimates that
more than 300 unaccredited university sites exist, with one
to two new sites cropping up each week.
Just because a university is accredited does not mean that
it is legitimate. Additionally, not all unaccredited universities
are fraudulent. In the United States, an accrediting agency
must be recognized by either the Department of Education or
the Council on Higher Education Accreditation.
The anonymity of the Internet makes it virtually impossible
to find con artists who operate fake virtual universities
from remote locations, such as the Grand Caymans or Costa
Rica.
"The biggest problem is the ease with which a huckster
with a few hundred dollars in his pocket can make a convincing
appearance on the Internet," said Rodney Merrill, founder
of DegreeFinders.com.
"You can easily steal the source code and graphics of
a real online university and change a few things and ... boom
-- you have a virtually virtual university. The Internet is
ripe for con men to strike their marks by the thousands."
Harrington University is headquartered in London, but students
must wire payments overseas through Western Union.
The service provides employers with transcripts and recommendation
letters, all without any grades or coursework. For an additional
fee, applicants may change any dates or majors within a year
of purchase.
Another school, Capitol University, uses the degree-mill.com
domain to offer applicants a "valid degree entirely from
job experience ... within 14 days."
Wired News was unable to contact Capitol University through
the phone number listed on the website.
Some illegitimate sites use Tongan ISPs to establish anonymity.
Others use the .edu domain suffix, which many people associate
with legitimate educational institutions.
The Internet's ability to deliver targeted ads to consumers
has also allowed illegitimate sites to thrive.
"The real villains are the media who take the ads,"
Bear said. "The only reason these sites prosper is because
people want them."
Some say that although people who sign up for diploma mills
may be defrauded, the real victims are unknowing employers
and the public.
"The majority of people know what they're doing,"
Bear said.
A bogus degree "is like putting a time bomb in your
resumé," he added. "One never knows when
it might go off with dire effects."
Diploma mills may also victimize the people who put their
trust in physicians, psychologists, lawyers, and others with
fake credentials.
Gregory Caplinger was indicted for wire fraud after claiming
to be an accomplished medical doctor with two fake medical
degrees and over 20 years of botched treatments.
Caplinger posed as an M.D. in North Carolina and Florida,
where he was arrested and charged with practicing medicine
without a license.
"There are people out there with fake degrees doing
terrible things," Bear said. "The human damage can
be considerable."
Fake degrees have also been found among military and government
officials, Bear said. One virtual university even offers a
mail-order degree in nuclear engineering safety. "Yet
most people don't take [diploma mills] seriously," Bear
said.
Educators and law enforcement officials are reluctant to prosecute
and slow to keep up with the growing rate of online diploma
mills. Additionally, accreditation laws vary across different
states, and some states have lenient rules with loopholes
that allow diploma mills to operate.
Bear estimates that there are more than 50 unaccredited universities
in Hawaii, where accreditation rules were virtually nonexistent
until recently.
"The laws are so vague that the most outrageous diploma
mills can stay in business as long as they continue the pretense
of being legitimate," Degree Finders.com's Merrill said.
Additionally, individuals who have been defrauded have little
recourse. Perpetrators who face lawsuits may disappear, change
their name, or file for bankruptcy.
The state of Louisiana shut down Columbia State University
for defrauding students. The correspondence school's founder
has since fled the country and allegedly remains a fugitive.
"Anyone who sues a diploma mill will most likely be
sued themselves," Merrill said. "The law favors
diploma mill operators, not the people who want to shut them
down."
Diploma mills also threaten legitimate distance-learning
institutions, whose reputations and enrollments may suffer
as they lose students to bogus schools.
"An enlightened public is our best hope," agreed
Bear. "I really think that public awareness can help."
"I want people to become a little more skeptical,"
Bear said.
He tells people that the next time they go to the doctor's
office, check the degree on the wall. "It doesn't hurt
to ask."
|